Choose the Right Tier for Your Claim
MyFairClaim is self-service, so you stay in control of your claim and keep everything you recover. Every plan includes the same appraisal report; the plans differ in how much step-by-step help comes with it for filing, negotiating and, if you need it, escalating. Already have your report? You can add any guide later, when you need it.
The evidence, ready to send. You handle the claim.
What you get
- The appraisal reportCompares your car with up to 20 similar cars for sale near you, adjusts for the differences and shows its value before and after the accident, with every step of the math.
- Every listing citedEach one names the dealer, price and miles, so the adjuster can check it.
- Listings we didn't use, and whyRejected listings are shown with the reason, so nobody can say the comparables were cherry-picked.
- Signed and verifiableA page the adjuster can open online confirms the report is genuine.
- Your state's ruleWhether your state recognizes diminished value and its time limit, with a link to our state guide.
- Two free updatesIf your repair bill, mileage, damage details, an earlier accident or the insurer's figure changes, we reissue the report for the same vehicle.
- Usually ready within minutesBuilt as soon as you add your claim details, then on your report page with a link by email.
- Questions answeredOur claims team answers by email and phone.
- Money-back guaranteeFull refund if we can't build your report, and 7 days money-back if it goes unused.
You'll still do
Write the claim letter, find out where and how to send it, track the deadlines, and answer the insurer.
Best if the insurer has already agreed to pay and just wants documentation.
Need the demand letter later? Add the Claim Kit for $25.
The evidence, plus your claim written and ready to file. Most people start here.
What you get
- Everything in the Report plan
- Your demand letter and emailWritten from your report, ready to sign and send.
- Claim KitA few short steps: your details, your letter, your email, then sending it.
- Sent the right wayWhat to include and how to send it so there is a record it arrived.
- Your state's deadlinesYour time limit to claim and the dates to watch while you wait.
- Help while you fileStuck on a step? Our claims team answers by email and phone.
- Yours to keepThe guide and your letter never expire, so you can come back to them any time.
You'll still do
Sign and send it, then answer the insurer yourself if it pushes back.
Best if you haven't filed your claim yet.
Insurer comes back low? Add the Dispute Kit later for $50.
Everything to file, plus a plan for when the insurer pushes back.
What you get
- Everything in Claim Kit
- Dispute Kit: RepliesPick what the insurer did (a low offer, a 10% or 17c formula, asking to record you, a denial or no answer) and get the reply to send and notes for the call.
- A log of every contactKeeps each call and letter on record in case you need to escalate.
- Your state's deadlines for the insurerHow fast the insurer must acknowledge and decide your claim, and what you can do when it misses those dates.
- Dispute Kit: EscalationChecks your claim against your state's deadlines for the insurer, fills in a complaint to your state insurance department and prepares a notice to the at-fault driver.
- Small claims stepsHow to take it to court, including the filing fee and where to file.
- Yours to keepAll three guides never expire, so they are there whenever the insurer answers.
You'll still do
Pick what the insurer said, then send what the guide gives you.
Best if the insurer has offered less, quoted a formula or said no, or you expect a fight.
What's in each plan, line by line
Every plan includes the same report. A claim has three steps: know your number, ask the insurer to pay, and push back if they offer too little. The Claim Kit helps with step 2; the Dispute Kit adds step 3.
Start smaller, upgrade any time. You only pay the difference: Report to Claim Kit $25, Report to Dispute Kit $75, Claim Kit to Dispute Kit $50. Your report stays the same.
Totaled car? The total loss plans follow the same steps: the report adds your state's sales tax and fees and the gap to the insurer's offer, the Claim Kit writes your settlement letter, and the Dispute Kit covers your policy's appraisal clause. See how a total loss report works
How 5 diminished value services compare
Prices and policies as stated on each company's website, checked November 21, 2026. Click a cell to see the source. MyFairClaim is our service.
"Not stated" means we didn't find it on the company's site. It doesn't mean they don't offer it. Spot an error? Email us and we'll fix it.
Which one should you use?
A market-data report like ours is usually enough when:
- the other driver was at fault and you're claiming against their insurer
- the insurer wants documentation, not a courtroom expert
- your car is a common model with plenty of local listings to compare
- you're comfortable filing the claim yourself
Pay for a licensed appraiser when:
- the claim is heading to court, arbitration or an appraisal-clause dispute, and you'll need someone to testify
- the insurer or your attorney asks for a licensed or USPAP appraisal
- the car is exotic, classic or heavily modified, with few comparable listings
- you want an inspection that documents repair quality
Ready to start? You can order a diminished value appraisal from $74.99.
What Does a Diminished Value Appraisal Cost?
The market for DV appraisals spans a wide range depending on the provider, methodology, and what's included beyond the core report.
Price is one side of it; the other is the figure you get. Our data on popular used cars shows how a market-based figure compares with the insurer's 17c number, and How we calculate shows what goes into ours.
You do the filing. We're here when you need us
MyFairClaim is self-service: you send the report and talk to the insurer yourself, which is why it costs a fraction of a hired appraiser. You're not on your own, though. Our claims team answers questions by email and phone.
Diminished Value Appraisal Cost FAQ
How much does a diminished value appraisal cost?
Most appraisal firms charge $250 to $425 for a report, according to their published prices in November 2026. Claim help or court testimony costs extra. MyFairClaim's report is $74.99.
Is there a free diminished value appraisal?
No one we found offers a free full appraisal. Free calculators, including ours, give an estimate using a formula, not the evidence an insurer expects.
Do I need a licensed appraiser for a diminished value claim?
Many third-party claims settle on documentation alone. Insurers generally weigh the evidence, not the title of the person who prepared it. For court, arbitration or an appraisal-clause dispute, a licensed appraiser who can testify is the safer choice.
Is a $74.99 report as credible as a $500 one?
Credibility comes from methodology, not price. MyFairClaim reports are built on current dealer listings using our published method. The lower price reflects a remote, automated workflow rather than field inspection overhead. The documentation is built to the standard insurers and courts expect.
Which plan do I need?
Think about where your claim is. If you just need the number, or the insurer already agreed to pay, the Report is enough. If you haven’t asked the insurer for the money yet, Claim Kit adds a demand letter written for you and step-by-step help sending it. If the insurer already offered too little or said no, the Dispute Kit adds ready replies, a state complaint and small claims steps. You can start small and add the rest later for the difference.
Why do in-person appraisals cost more?
Local appraisers physically inspect your vehicle, which requires travel, scheduling, and time. That overhead is real and gets passed on. For most diminished value claims, a remote appraisal using VIN-based vehicle history, repair documentation, and current dealer listings near you produces the same quality outcome without the wait or the added cost.
Can I add help after I order?
Yes. You can add any guide later, when you need it: either dispute guide for $39.99, both dispute guides for $50, or the Claim Kit for $25 if you started with the Report. Choosing a plan up front is still the best deal.
What if the insurer rejects the report?
That’s what the Dispute Kit is for. Its replies guide helps you answer a low offer or denial point by point, and its escalation guide walks you through appraisal clause invocation, Department of Insurance complaints and small claims. Both come with the Dispute Kit, and either can be added later on its own.
What’s the money-back guarantee?
We offer a 7-day money-back guarantee if the report has not been used, meaning it has not been submitted to an insurer, included in a demand letter, or used in any claim or dispute. Requests must be submitted in writing to [email protected] from the email address used to place the order within 7 calendar days of delivery.