How We Calculate Diminished Value | MyFairClaim Methodology Skip to main content
Talk to a real person 7 AM to 9 PM Eastern, every dayCall (602) 935-4309Chat with us
Get my report

How MyFairClaim calculates diminished value

A diminished value number is only as strong as the evidence behind it. This page shows where ours comes from: the data, the steps, and what we check along the way. Nothing here is a black box, and every figure in your report can be traced back to it. Your report values your car at its mileage on the day of the accident and as of your date of loss, not as it is today. Our guides follow the process on How We Write and Review, and About MyFairClaim covers who we are.

MyFairClaim Claims TeamBy the MyFairClaim Claims Team · Last updated October 2026
5+Comparable vehicles required, within 100 miles; any wider search is labeled in your report
50 + D.C.States and jurisdictions covered
100 miWhere every search starts. If fewer than five match, we look farther and your report says how far.

From your VIN to a documented number

01Establish the pre-loss value
We find dealer listings for vehicles that match yours by year, make, model and trim within 100 miles of where your car is kept. Each comparable is adjusted to your car's mileage on the day of the accident and for differences in configuration, and every adjustment is shown so the result can be reproduced. Listings are today's prices, so we then value your car as of your date of loss: the government's used car price index shows how prices have moved since then, and an age adjustment accounts for your car being newer on that day.
Dealer listings from our own database of more than 1 million vehicle values
Mileage and configuration adjustments shown line by line
Valued as of your date of loss, at your mileage that day
A reconciliation of the median, mean and range of adjusted values
02Measure the loss in value
Buyers pay less for a car with a reported accident. We measure that discount from the documented damage and repairs, together with the car's age, mileage and market, and show each factor and its effect in the report.
Based on the documented damage and repairs
Adjusted for the vehicle's age, mileage and market
Every factor shown in your report
03Validate the data
Before a report is issued, the comparable set has to meet minimum standards. The report shows each standard, the requirement and whether it was met.
At least 5 comparable vehicles
All within 100 miles
Mileage within 10,000 of your car
Adjusted values within a 15% spread
VIN decoded and trim confirmed
04Document it for the adjuster
Everything goes into your Diminished Value Appraisal Report: a written conclusion of value, the comparable sales, the loss calculation, the applicable state law and a certification from MyFairClaim LLC.
Scope of work, sources and assumptions stated plainly
A verification link so anyone can confirm the report is authentic

Why the report is the number to send

The free calculator works only from what you tell it: your car's value, mileage at the time of the accident and damage level, plus the date of loss and repair amount if you add them. With a date of loss, it moves the value you enter to that date using the government's used car price index. It prices the least favorable case within each answer, so the range is deliberately conservative. Your report replaces your answers with real comparable sales for your exact vehicle, your actual repair details and a documented loss calculation. As long as your car and damage match what you entered, it will not come in below the free estimate.

Worked example from the sample report2022 Toyota RAV4 XLE AWD · 31,200 miles · $9,120 repair with structural damage · 7 comparables near Albany, NY
Pre-loss market value$30,136
Post-loss market value$25,263
Diminished value$4,873
Open the full sample report (PDF)Diminished value overview slides (PDF)Total loss overview slides (PDF)

Where the numbers come from

Our vehicle value databaseMore than 1 million vehicle values our own crawler reads from dealer websites in all 50 states + D.C., refreshed daily: asking price, mileage, location, days on market and price history. Asking prices are reduced a flat 2% to estimate selling prices. How the database works.
VIN decodeYour VIN is decoded through the federal NHTSA database and the trim is confirmed against matching listings, so the comparables match your car.
Your documentsRepair cost, accident date and damage details you provide, plus your repair estimate or invoice.
Used car price indexThe U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics' monthly Consumer Price Index for used cars and trucks. It moves today's listing prices to your date of loss, up or down, and your report shows both index values.

Every month we run this same method on current listings for popular used cars and publish the results on our diminished value data page.

Page 1: Conclusion of valuePre-loss value, post-loss value and the diminished value, in writing.Sample page from the Page 1: Conclusion of valueOpen the full sample (PDF)
Page 2: Comparable salesHow the comparables were chosen and adjusted, with every listing and its dealer details in the addendum, so the number can be reproduced.Sample page from the Page 2: Comparable salesOpen the full sample (PDF)

Is this a USPAP appraisal?

No, and it isn't meant to be. USPAP (the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice) is the rulebook a licensed appraiser follows when they personally prepare an appraisal: they research the vehicle, choose comparables by hand and write up their own opinion of value. That usually takes days and costs $250 to $600.

MyFairClaim works differently. It's an automated valuation system: one published method, applied the same way to every car, using current dealer listings matched to your vehicle. Every comparable, adjustment and calculation is shown in the report, automatic checks run on every report and a member of our team reviews any report they flag, and anyone can check a report with its report number. Most reports are ready in minutes.

MyFairClaim report
USPAP appraisal
Who prepares it
An automated system using one published method, with automatic checks and a person reviewing any report they flag
A licensed appraiser, individually
How the value is set
At least five listings of similar cars for sale near you, with every adjustment shown as a dollar amount
The appraiser's own research and opinion
Time
Usually minutes
Usually days
Cost
From $74.99
Usually $250 to $600
Can the insurer check it?
Yes: every listing is cited and the report number can be verified
Depends on the appraiser's write-up

Does it matter for my claim?

For most claims you settle directly with the insurer, nothing requires a USPAP appraisal. What moves an adjuster is evidence they can check: real comparable vehicles, stated adjustments and a clear number. That is what the report gives you.

When you may want a licensed appraiser

If your claim goes to court, an attorney asks for a credentialed appraiser's opinion, or you invoke your policy's appraisal clause, you may need a licensed appraiser. Your report still helps: it gives them the market data to start from.

The honest limits

We don't inspect the vehicle in person. The report relies on your VIN, your repair records and public market data, so accurate inputs matter.
We don't guarantee a settlement amount. The report documents the loss and the insurer still has to agree. If they push back, the Dispute Kit (or its guides, added later) helps you respond or escalate, and our team is a reply away.
We're not a law firm and don't give legal advice. For advice on your situation, talk to an attorney licensed in your state.
MyFairClaim Claims Team
MyFairClaim Claims TeamWorking auto claims professionals
Every figure in the report traces back to a real listing or a stated factor. If an adjuster pushes back, point them to the comparables, not the conclusion.
The MyFairClaim Claims Team writes and reviews every guide on this site using official state sources and real local sales data.
Posts on LinkedInRead our guides
Put the method to work on your carFree estimate in about a minute. Reports from $74.99.

MyFairClaim is self-service, backed by people. You enter the details. We build your report and guides. You send it to the insurer. You file your own claim; we don't contact your insurer for you. Our claims team answers questions through the chat on this page or by email at [email protected].

Questions? Talk to a real person.We answer chat and calls 7 AM to 9 PM Eastern, every day.
Chat with usCall (602) 935-4309
What did your car lose?See my free estimate
You've been opted out of analytics and advertising cookies.