How to Get a Diminished Value Appraisal, Step by Step Skip to main content
Talk to a real person 7 AM to 9 PM Eastern, every dayCall (602) 935-4309Chat with us
Get my report

How to Get a Diminished Value Appraisal: Where, When and What It Must Include

Where Can I Get a Diminished Value Report

Reviewed by the MyFairClaim Claims Team · How we write and review

Here is how to get a diminished value appraisal: wait until your car is fully repaired, gather your repair invoice, photos and vehicle details, and order a market-based appraisal from an independent appraiser or an online diminished value appraisal report, not from the insurance company. Independent appraisers typically charge about $250 to $600 for a standard report; online reports cost less (ours start at $74.99). Before you send it to the insurer, check that it compares real sales of similar cars with and without accident history and explains how it reached its number. Then attach it to your demand letter. If you\’re ready to order, get a diminished value appraisal online from $74.99.

Want one built from cars like yours for sale near you? See how a MyFairClaim diminished value appraisal works and what it costs. For the steps after the appraisal, see how to file a diminished value claim.

This guide covers where to get an appraisal, what it should cost, what a credible report must include, and the red flags that tell you a report will not hold up.

What a Diminished Value Appraisal Is (and What It Is Not)

A diminished value appraisal is a written report that measures how much market value your car lost because it now has an accident history. It compares what your car was worth just before the accident with what it is worth after repair, using sales of comparable vehicles. That number is the evidence behind your diminished value claim.

We compare what appraisals cost from different providers on our appraisal cost page, and How we calculate shows exactly what goes into ours.

Several things look similar but are not appraisals:

  • The insurer’s offer. Most insurers use the 17c formula, which caps the loss at 10% of the car’s value and then cuts it further with damage and mileage multipliers. It is the insurer’s opening position, not an independent valuation.
  • A free online estimate. A diminished value calculator gives you a quick range so you can decide whether a claim is worth pursuing. It is a starting point, not a document you can submit.
  • A body shop repair estimate. It prices the repair. It says nothing about what the repaired car is now worth.
  • A dealer trade-in quote. A written quote can be useful supporting evidence, but on its own it is one buyer’s offer, not a market analysis.

When to Get Your Appraisal

Get it after the repairs are finished. A credible appraisal relies on the final repair invoice: what was damaged, what was replaced, and whether the parts were original manufacturer (OEM) or aftermarket. An appraisal done from the first estimate can miss supplements and hidden damage found during repair.

Get it before you send your demand, so your demand states a specific, supported amount. And get it well inside your deadline. Most states allow 2 to 6 years for property damage claims, but some leave less room than people expect. Check your state’s deadline. Market data also ages, so a report built on last month’s sales carries more weight than one built on sales from a year ago.

Where to Get a Diminished Value Appraisal

OptionTypical costTurnaroundBest for
Independent local appraiserAbout $250 to $600 for a desk appraisal; more for in-person or court workUsually several business daysHigh-value or unusual vehicles, and claims likely to end up in court
Online diminished value appraisal serviceLower; varies by serviceSame day to a few daysEveryday vehicles and most third-party claims
Contingency service (paid from your settlement)A share of what you recover, often with a minimum feeVariesPeople who cannot pay up front; read the fee terms closely
An appraiser hired by your attorneyUsually billed through the attorneyVariesLarger claims already in litigation
The insurance companyFree to youVariesNot recommended: its number is the one you are disputing

Whichever option you choose, the appraiser should be independent of the insurer and willing to explain the method in writing. Ask to see a sample report before you pay. If a provider will not show you what you are buying, keep looking. This is a different report from the insurer’s own car appraisal, which only sets the repair estimate or the total loss value.

What an Appraisal Costs

Independent appraisers usually charge a few hundred dollars for a standard desk appraisal, and more for luxury cars, in-person inspections or court work. Contingency services charge nothing up front but take a share of what you recover. Online reports cost less: MyFairClaim’s start at $74.99. For a side-by-side of local appraisers, attorneys and online services, see what a diminished value appraisal costs.

Can you get the fee back? Often you can ask. Include the appraisal fee in your demand amount. In many states, appraisal fees are recoverable as damages, especially when an insurer handled the claim in bad faith, but insurers frequently refuse to pay it in settlement.

What a Credible Appraisal Must Include

An adjuster will look for reasons to discount your report. Make sure it includes:

  1. Full vehicle identification: year, make, model, trim, VIN, mileage and major options.
  2. Pre-accident value, supported by sales of comparable clean-history vehicles, with the sources named.
  3. Damage and repair details from the final repair invoice, including whether structural or frame damage was involved and whether OEM parts were used.
  4. Post-repair value, supported by comparable sales of vehicles with similar accident histories, or a clearly explained market adjustment.
  5. Comparable vehicles that actually match yours in year, trim, mileage and region, with dates and prices listed.
  6. A written explanation of the method, showing how each comparable was adjusted and how the final figure was reached.
  7. A specific dollar amount for the diminished value, not just a range.
  8. The valuation date and the date the report was prepared.
  9. Who prepared it, with a statement that they have no financial interest in the outcome.
  10. Supporting documents: photos, the repair invoice, and the vehicle history report if it shows the accident.

Red Flags: Reports That Will Not Hold Up

  • 17c in disguise. If the report starts from a 10% cap and applies damage and mileage multipliers, it is the insurer’s formula with a different cover page. An adjuster will simply match it.
  • No comparables, or comparables that do not match your car’s trim, mileage or region.
  • No explanation of how the number was reached. A figure without a method is an opinion.
  • A guaranteed result. No honest appraiser can promise what an insurer will pay.
  • Ties to the insurer. An appraiser who mostly works for insurance companies is not the right choice for your side of the claim.

How to Get Your Appraisal, Step by Step

  1. Confirm you have a claim. Diminished value is usually recovered from the at-fault driver’s insurer. Check your state’s rules, including its fault rule and deadline.
  2. Finish the repairs and get the final, itemized repair invoice.
  3. Gather your documents: VIN, mileage, photos before and after repair, the claim number, and the at-fault driver’s insurance details.
  4. Get a quick estimate with the diminished value calculator to see whether a claim is worth pursuing.
  5. Order a market-based appraisal from an independent source, and check it against the list above.
  6. Send it with your demand. Attach the appraisal and repair invoice to a written demand letter, and keep proof of delivery.

Is a Diminished Value Appraisal Worth It?

Usually, when the gap between the insurer’s 17c number and the market loss is larger than the appraisal fee. On a 2022 Honda Accord worth $29,900 with moderate damage and 26,000 miles, the 17c formula produces $1,196. A market-based appraisal of the same car put the loss at $4,750. A few hundred dollars for the report, or less, was the cost of documenting a gap of more than $3,500.

An appraisal is less likely to pay off on an older, high-mileage car with only cosmetic damage, or in a state that limits diminished value recovery. If you are unsure, start with a free estimate and your state guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my body shop do a diminished value appraisal?

Usually not. A body shop can document the repair, and its invoice is an important part of your evidence, but measuring market value loss requires comparable sales research that repair shops do not normally perform.

Does the insurance company have to accept my appraisal?

No law forces an insurer to accept it, but a documented, market-based appraisal is evidence the adjuster has to answer. If the insurer refuses to engage, you can file a complaint with your state’s Department of Insurance or take the claim to small claims court. See what to do if your claim is denied.

Does the appraiser need to inspect my car in person?

Not usually. Most diminished value appraisals are desk appraisals built from the repair invoice, photos and market data. An in-person inspection can help for high-value or unusual vehicles, or when the repair quality itself is in dispute.

How long does a diminished value appraisal take?

Independent appraisers commonly take several business days. Online services are often faster. MyFairClaim reports are usually ready within a few minutes.

What happens after I get the appraisal?

Send it to the at-fault insurer with a written demand. There is no official claim form; your letter and appraisal are the claim. Use our demand letter and claim form template.

Related Guides

MyFairClaim is self-service, backed by people. You enter the details. We build your report and guides. You send it to the insurer. You file your own claim; we don't contact your insurer for you. Our claims team answers questions through the chat on this page or by email at [email protected].

Questions? Talk to a real person.We answer chat and calls 7 AM to 9 PM Eastern, every day.
Chat with usCall (602) 935-4309
What did your car lose?See my free estimate
You've been opted out of analytics and advertising cookies.
Free estimateGet my report $74.99