How much does the 17c formula underpay diminished value?
For a common structural repair, our method puts the loss in value at 2.0 times what the insurer's 17c formula would offer, on average across 20 of America's most popular used vehicles. For a moderate repair, the gap is 3.0 times.
Updated November 6, 2026 from current dealer listings within 100 miles of Atlanta, GA. Every figure is calculated, not reported by customers or insurers; see how below.
Scope: one metro area (Atlanta, GA), one model year (2022) and one mileage (36,000 miles). Prices and losses differ in other markets, so treat these as a benchmark, not a quote for your car.
Severe repair: our method compared with 17c
Our method 17c formula
The biggest loss in this run: the 2022 Ford F-150 at $8,461. The smallest: the 2022 Nissan Rogue at $2,723. Higher-value vehicles lose more dollars, but 17c caps every one of them at a slice of 10% of value.
All figures
| Vehicle | Pre-accident value | Listings used | Moderate: 17c | Moderate: our method | Severe: 17c | Severe: our method |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 Ford F-150 | $44,223 | 9 | $1,769 | $5,475 | $3,538 | $8,461 |
| 2022 Toyota Highlander | $35,476 | 10 | $1,419 | $4,268 | $2,838 | $6,038 |
| 2022 Ram 1500 | $33,265 | 12 | $1,331 | $3,986 | $2,661 | $5,484 |
| 2022 Toyota Tacoma | $32,455 | 6 | $1,298 | $3,885 | $2,596 | $5,287 |
| 2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 | $31,827 | 8 | $1,273 | $3,808 | $2,546 | $5,136 |
| 2022 Tesla Model 3 | $31,500 | 18 | $1,260 | $3,768 | $2,520 | $5,059 |
| 2022 Ford Explorer | $28,151 | 5 | $1,126 | $3,338 | $2,252 | $4,354 |
| 2022 Subaru Outback | $26,922 | 12 | $1,077 | $3,177 | $2,154 | $4,125 |
| 2022 Honda CR-V | $26,617 | 7 | $1,065 | $3,138 | $2,129 | $4,069 |
| 2022 Jeep Grand Cherokee | $26,086 | 7 | $1,043 | $3,069 | $2,087 | $3,972 |
| 2022 Toyota RAV4 | $25,957 | 6 | $1,038 | $3,053 | $2,077 | $3,949 |
| 2022 Toyota Camry | $25,436 | 13 | $1,017 | $2,987 | $2,035 | $3,855 |
| 2022 Honda Accord | $25,134 | 9 | $1,005 | $2,949 | $2,011 | $3,801 |
| 2022 Mazda CX-5 | $24,871 | 6 | $995 | $2,918 | $1,990 | $3,757 |
| 2022 Honda Civic | $24,303 | 9 | $972 | $2,853 | $1,944 | $3,664 |
| 2022 Kia Sportage | $22,146 | 18 | $886 | $2,613 | $1,772 | $3,321 |
| 2022 Hyundai Tucson | $20,630 | 9 | $825 | $2,449 | $1,650 | $3,089 |
| 2022 Chevrolet Equinox | $19,605 | 8 | $784 | $2,342 | $1,568 | $2,936 |
| 2022 Toyota Corolla | $19,572 | 5 | $783 | $2,338 | $1,566 | $2,931 |
| 2022 Nissan Rogue | $18,140 | 8 | $726 | $2,191 | $1,451 | $2,723 |
What the 17c formula is
17c is the shortcut most insurers use to price diminished value. It comes from paragraph 17(c) of the settlement in State Farm v. Mabry, a 2001 Georgia case. It is not a statute or an appraisal standard. The formula takes 10% of the car's value, then multiplies it by a damage factor and a mileage factor, so it can never exceed 10% of value. Our guide on how diminished value is calculated has the full multiplier tables.
In this run, every car has 36,000 miles, which carries a 17c mileage factor of 0.80. The moderate repair uses a damage factor of 0.50 and the structural repair 1.00. For the 2022 Ford F-150, that is $44,223 × 10% × 1.00 × 0.80 = $3,538 for the structural repair.
Reading these figures
- Pre-accident value is what a clean-history car like this sells for nearby, from the median of the listings used.
- 17c is what an insurer's formula would likely offer for the same car and repair.
- Our method is the loss our reports would document for the same inputs. It is a benchmark, not an offer or a guarantee.
- Listings used is how many comparable vehicles met our standards. Each figure needs at least 5.
How we ran it
- Vehicles: the 2022 model year of 20 popular used models, any trim except hybrids, at 36,000 miles.
- Pre-accident value: the median of comparable dealer listings within 100 miles of Atlanta, GA, adjusted for mileage and less 2% to convert asking prices to selling prices, exactly as in our reports.
- Two damage scenarios: Moderate: $4,500 repair, parts replaced; Severe: $9,000 repair with structural work.
- 17c: 10% of the pre-accident value, times the damage and mileage modifiers insurers use.
- Our method: the same published method as every MyFairClaim report (how we calculate). Your own car, damage and market will give a different number.
- Refreshed every 30 days.
How to cite this data
MyFairClaim, “Diminished Value on Popular Used Cars,” updated November 6, 2026, https://myfairclaim.com/diminished-value-data/. Journalists and researchers are welcome to use these figures with a link to this page; email [email protected] with questions about the method.
Related guides
- How we calculate diminished value
- How diminished value is calculated: 17c and market value
- How much an accident decreases car value
- How an accident on Carfax affects resale value
- How to get diminished value from insurance
- Diminished value demand letter
- What a diminished value report includes
- Diminished value laws by state
- How each insurer handles diminished value