
Reviewed by the MyFairClaim Claims Team · How we write and review
After a crash that was not your fault, knowing the right steps can be the difference between getting back everything you lost and leaving thousands of dollars behind. In the minutes after a crash, most people think about what is in front of them, not the money choices that will affect them for years. Insurers count on that.
This checklist was put together by insurance adjusters who have handled claims from the insurer’s side. These are the steps that protect your rights, your health, and the full value of your claim. They are listed in order of priority.
Step 1: Check for Injuries and Call 911
First, check yourself and your passengers for injuries. Do not assume you are fine just because you feel fine right after the crash. Adrenaline hides pain. Injuries like whiplash and back strain often do not show up until hours or days later.
Call 911 even if the crash seems small. A police report is an official record of what happened, who was there and who got a ticket. Without one, any fight over fault becomes your word against the other driver’s. Many insurers use a missing police report to slow down or deny a claim.
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration says millions of people are hurt in car crashes each year, and many injuries are not reported at the scene. Do not decide for yourself at the roadside that you are not hurt.
Step 2: Document Everything at the Scene
While you wait for the police, use your phone to record as much as you can. This protects you if the other driver changes their story later, or if the insurer argues about what happened.
Take photos and video of these before anything is moved:
- All four sides of both vehicles, including close-up shots of all damage
- The position of both vehicles in the roadway before they are moved
- The license plates of all vehicles involved
- Any skid marks, debris, or road conditions relevant to the accident
- The other driver’s license, insurance card and registration
- The names and contact information of any witnesses
- The badge number and name of the responding officer
- The police report number (you will need this to request the full report later)
If anyone saw the crash, ask them to stay until the police come, or get their phone number. What a neutral witness says counts for a lot when fault is in question.
Step 3: Do Not Admit Fault or Apologize
This is one of the most common and costly mistakes people make at an accident scene. A simple “I’m sorry” said out of instinct can be interpreted as an admission of liability. Say nothing about fault to the other driver, witnesses, or bystanders. Stick to exchanging insurance information.
This goes for talking to adjusters too. You have to cooperate with your own insurer. But you usually do not have to give a recorded statement to the at-fault driver’s insurer. If you are hurt, talk to a lawyer before you give any recorded statement.
Step 4: Seek Medical Attention Promptly
See a doctor as soon as possible after the accident, even if you feel fine. For two reasons: first, your health is the priority. Second, a gap between the accident and your first medical visit is frequently used by insurance adjusters to argue that your injuries were not caused by the collision.
Keep records of every doctor visit, diagnosis, treatment, prescription and cost you paid yourself because of the crash. If you are hurt, these records are the base of an injury claim.
Step 5: Report the Accident to Your Own Insurance Company
Tell your own insurer about the crash soon, even if the other driver was at fault. Most policies require you to report it quickly to keep your coverage. Your insurer can help work with the at-fault driver’s insurer and may cover a rental car while yours is in the shop.
Stick to the facts in your report. Say what happened without guessing who was at fault. Your insurer will look into it on its own.
Step 6: Get Your Vehicle Repaired Through the At-Fault Driver’s Insurance
You have the right to have your vehicle repaired through the at-fault driver’s liability coverage. This means their insurance pays for repairs, not yours. You should not have to use your own collision coverage or pay a deductible when the other driver caused the accident.
Request a copy of the complete repair estimate or final repair invoice from the shop. You will need this document for the step most people miss entirely, covered next.
The Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I) has plain-language guides to car insurance and claims.
Step 7: What to Do After a Car Accident: File a Diminished Value Claim
This is the step that costs most people thousands of dollars, because no one tells them about it. A diminished value report backs the claim with comparable listings.
Knowing what to do after a crash that was not your fault is the first step to getting your whole claim paid.
Once your car is fixed, it is worth less than the same car that was never in a crash. Any buyer, dealer or appraiser who checks a Carfax report will see the accident and offer less. That lasting drop in value is called inherent diminished value, and you have the right to claim it from the at-fault driver’s insurer.
Diminished value is a separate claim from your repair costs. The at-fault insurer pays for the repairs, and then you file an additional claim for the loss in market value. These are two distinct compensable losses.
Most insurers will not tell you that you have this right. They are counting on you not knowing.
How Much Diminished Value Are You Owed?
The amount depends on what your car was worth before the crash, how bad the damage was, and its miles and condition. Pricier cars with heavy damage usually lose the most. A newer luxury car with a big repair can lose 15% to 25% of its value, even after a perfect repair.
Use our free diminished value calculator to get a quick estimate for your car. It takes about a minute and gives you a rough number before you decide whether to file a claim.
How to File a Diminished Value Claim
To file a diminished value claim, you need four things:
- The completed repair invoice showing what was repaired and the total cost
- A Carfax or AutoCheck report that shows the accident on your car’s history
- A pre-accident market value from Kelley Blue Book or NADA
- An independent diminished value appraisal that shows your own loss
The appraisal is the most important paper. Without one, you are bargaining against the insurer’s own number, which is always lower than the real loss. A report built from real sales of cars like yours gives you a number the adjuster has to answer.
The Claim Kit includes your diminished value report and a demand letter written for you. It is ready to send to the at-fault insurer. It is the documentation package adjusters take seriously because it was built by people who used to review these claims from the other side.
Which Insurer Do You Need to File Against?
You file a diminished value claim with the at-fault driver’s insurer, not your own. If the at-fault driver has State Farm, Progressive, GEICO or another big insurer, see our guides for how each one handles these claims:
- How to file a diminished value claim with State Farm
- How to file a diminished value claim with Geico
- How to file a diminished value claim with Progressive
Step 8: Keep Records of Everything
Make one folder, paper or digital, for everything about the crash. Put in the police report, all letters and emails with insurers, repair estimates and bills, medical records and bills, rental car receipts and any photos or video from the scene.
Insurance claims can take weeks or months to resolve. Detailed records protect you at every stage and are essential if you need to escalate a dispute or consult an attorney.
Step 9: Know the Time Limits on Your Claims
Every state has a deadline (a statute of limitations) for property damage and injury claims. For car damage it runs from 2 to 10 years depending on the state, and for injuries it can be as short as 1 year in some states. If you miss it, you can lose your claim for good, no matter how strong it is.
In most states, diminished value claims have the same deadline as repair claims. File well before it. Claims filed soon after the repair is done also tend to settle better than ones filed months later.
Your own policy may also require you to report the crash and set shorter deadlines for some kinds of coverage. Read your policy or call your agent to see what applies to you.
Step 10: Consider Consulting an Attorney for Injuries
If you are hurt, an injury lawyer can protect you in ways this guide does not cover. Most injury lawyers work on contingency, which means they take a share of the payout instead of charging you up front.
For damage to your car only, including diminished value, you usually do not need a lawyer. You can handle these claims yourself with the right papers.
The One Thing Most People Get Wrong
Most not-at-fault accident victims do everything right through step 6 and then stop. They get their car repaired, take the insurer’s settlement for the repair costs, and move on. They do not know about diminished value. They sell or trade their vehicle a year later and lose thousands because of an accident that was not their fault, one they were never compensated for.
The repair restores the car. It does not restore the car’s value. Those are two different things, and only one of them gets addressed automatically.
If your car was fixed after a crash that was not your fault and you have not filed a diminished value claim, start with a free estimate to see what you may still be owed. Most states give you 2 to 3 years from the crash to file.
If the other car was driverless, see how claims against a Waymo work.
This guide was written by experienced insurance adjusters and appraisers. It is general information, not legal advice. If someone was badly hurt or fault is disputed, talk with a licensed lawyer in your state.
Related Guides
- How to Get Diminished Value from Insurance: step-by-step filing guide
- How Is Diminished Value Calculated?: why the 17c formula undervalues your claim
- Diminished Value Claim Form: template and how to file
- How Much Does an Accident Decrease Car Value?: real loss ranges by damage severity
- Free Diminished Value Calculator: see your loss in about a minute
The MyFairClaim Claims Team writes and reviews every guide on this site using official state sources and real local sales data. Each guide follows our published review process, and we update it when laws, court decisions or insurer practices change. Questions about a claim go to [email protected] or 602-935-4309.